blake348 發表於 2010-9-30 11:19:08

2500元的價位最佳顯卡大PK~Radeon HD 5550 VS GT220

在先前的測試中發現,PowerColor所推出的ATI Radeon HD 5550處於2500元的價位帶,定位為中低階的顯示卡,但是效能並不差,在解析度為1280x720的情況下不但可以特效全開的運行遊戲,還可以打開反鋸齒讓畫面更精細。那到底在這個價位代PowerColor HD5550 PCS+ 512M DDR5有沒有對手呢?正好,手邊有一張NVIDIA的GT220,價位與HD5550相近,當然一定要互相比較一下!

測試硬體
CPU: Phenom II X4 B50
MB: MSI 890GXM-G65
VGA: PowerColor HD 5550 512M GDDR5
RAM DDR3 1333 2Gx2
POWER: Zippy G1 500W

首先來看 3DMARK 06的測試比較
PowerColor HD5550 PCS+ 512M GDDR5
https://lh4.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9C5_FPpI/AAAAAAAAB6c/E7swUDUH2Mc/image001.jpg

ASUS ENGT220/DI/1GD3
https://lh4.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9D-O1nBI/AAAAAAAAB6g/ISnwtSMmOvo/image003.jpg

Final Fantasy XIV 1280X720的測試比較
PowerColor HD5550 PCS+ 512M GDDR5
https://lh3.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9ELc_6sI/AAAAAAAAB6k/qdKSJ9UtlnM/image005.jpg

ASUS ENGT220/DI/1GD3
https://lh6.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9E5CT0BI/AAAAAAAAB6o/xvvYjhs0BS4/image007.jpg

Lost Planet 2 Benchmark的測試比較
https://lh6.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9FC32qyI/AAAAAAAAB6s/gDpd-IhKMEk/image009.jpg

PowerColor HD5550 PCS+ 512M GDDR5
https://lh5.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9F21SVAI/AAAAAAAAB6w/_I4n78R_Tts/image011.jpg

ASUS ENGT220/DI/1GD3
https://lh3.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9GuYRtKI/AAAAAAAAB60/tVf-E2ZMe3o/image013.jpg

惡靈古堡五的測試比較
https://lh3.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9G8LA9BI/AAAAAAAAB64/mm-nZAaQBs8/image015.jpg
https://lh3.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9HWsW64I/AAAAAAAAB68/LiEiudQu_pg/image017.jpg

PowerColor HD5550 PCS+ 512M GDDR5
https://lh4.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9INhobvI/AAAAAAAAB7A/lY7noGj8xeI/image019.jpg

ASUS ENGT220/DI/1GD3
https://lh3.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9JV66jNI/AAAAAAAAB7E/r74CtSR7T3s/image021.jpg

快打旋風四的測試比較
https://lh5.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9KWFwI_I/AAAAAAAAB7I/6b48-Twkr-8/image023.jpg
https://lh4.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9LGvA6uI/AAAAAAAAB7M/_AkBVXvw748/image025.jpg

PowerColor HD5550 PCS+ 512M GDDR5
https://lh5.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9L6jGqKI/AAAAAAAAB7Q/xM6jEOtNdpk/image027.jpg

ASUS ENGT220/DI/1GD3
https://lh6.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9M393VlI/AAAAAAAAB7U/yLZZGcmrI8s/image029.jpg

MHFベンチマーク【絆】
PowerColor HD5550 PCS+ 512M GDDR5
https://lh3.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9NtEtPRI/AAAAAAAAB7Y/GDhC3B3aMGE/image031.jpg

ASUS ENGT220/DI/1GD3
https://lh5.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP9OZpkHDI/AAAAAAAAB7c/2wTOfspY8WQ/image033.jpg

https://lh5.ggpht.com/_l51mfv6mbKs/TKP_737--mI/AAAAAAAAB7o/ulm18nsTXtI/386.jpg
測試結果令人滿驚訝的,兩張價錢相近的顯示卡,效能卻有明顯的差別,而且相差幅度竟然從20%到70%都有,其中大部分的遊戲都是比較對NV有優化過的,這表示GT220的效能實在是很....:
如果近期內預算只有2500的朋友準備購卡,可以自己多比較一下囉 :lol

knighter9999 發表於 2010-9-30 23:00:03

GT220的定位是擺在低階入門顯卡
雖然說 HD5550也是
但是HD5550 的 512MBGDDR5應該多了不少分數!!!!

感謝大大精彩的詳細測試對比分享!!!!

Mio 發表於 2010-9-30 23:08:25

看來是5550勝阿:good
頁: [1]
查看完整版本: 2500元的價位最佳顯卡大PK~Radeon HD 5550 VS GT220